Andrew Erwin (birthname: Andrew David Erwin) has been an Evangelical Christian-based filmmaker since 2006, when he made (as director/editor with brother Jon) the documentary feature,
The Cross and the Towers (2006). Erwin served as film editor of the documentary,
Hearing Everett: The Rancho Sordo Mudo Story (2008), and then three years later was director/story writer/producer/editor of the anti-abortion drama,
October Baby (2011), with Rachel Hendrix and Jasmine Guy, earning $5.3 million on a $1 million budget.
Erwin was the film editor of the feature,
Fully Alive (2012), followed by the Sony-released comedy,
Moms’ Night Out (2014), for which he was director/producer/editor and which co-starred Sarah Drew, Sean Astin, Patricia Heaton, and Trace Adkins, and grossed $10.5 million globally. Erwin’s first commercial failure (as director/editor/executive producer) was the Christian football-themed
Woodlawn (2015), starring Sean Astin, Jon Voight, and C. Thomas Howell earned a poor $14.4 million gross for distributor Pure Flix Entertainment.
Andrew Erwin’s second documentary (with Jon) as producer was the little-seen
Steve McQueen: American Icon (2017), followed by one of the Erwin Brothers’ most successful features—with Andrew again as director/editor/executive producer--the Christian-themed biopic I Can Only Imagine (2018), with J. Michael Finley, Trace Adkins, Cloris Leachman, and
Dennis Quaid, returning a $86 million gross for distributors Lionsgate/Roadside Attractions. Director-writer-producer Erwin, as director/producer, didn’t have the same commercial returns with
I Still Believe (2020), with KJ Apa, Britt Robertson, Shania Twain, and Gary Sinise, which returned only $16.4 million in a Lionsgate release.
Erwin co-directed (with Jon) and executive producer the documentary,
The Jesus Music (2021), featuring Christian musicians including Amy Grant, Michael W. Smith, and Michael Tait, which returned a small $1 million box office for distributor Lionsgate, and then resumed his narrative projects as director/producer/editor with
American Underdog (2021), a movie dramatizing Los Angeles Rams quarterback Kurt Warner, starring
Zachary Levi, Anna Paquin, and
Dennis Quaid, and returning for Lionsgate a disappointing $26.5 million box office. Erwin’s next Christian drama (as producer only) was
Jesus Revolution (2023), with
Joel Courtney, Jonathan Roumie, and
Kelsey Grammer under the co-direction of brother Jon and
Brent McCorkle, followed by a producer credit on Ordinary Angels (2023), starring Hilary Swank and Alan Richson, for which his brother Jon was co-writer and co-producer.
Andrew Erwin then served as film editor on the commercially successful
The Best Christmas Pageant Ever (2024), starring
Judy Greer, Pete Holmes and Lauren Graham under
Dallas Jenkins’s direction and delivering a strong $40.3 million gross for distributor Lionsgate, followed by Andrew serving as a producer on director/writer
Jon Gunn’s long-delayed biopic,
The Unbreakable Boy (2025), starring Zachary Levi, Meghann Fahy, Jacob Laval and Patricia Heaton, produced by Kingdom Story Company and grossing over $7 million for Lionsgate. Erwin then co-directed (with co-director/writer Brent McCorkle). He was one of the producers of the sequel,
I Can Only Imagine 2 (2026),
starring John Michael Finley, Milo Ventimiglia, Sophie Skelton, Trace Adkins, and Dennis Quaid, and released widely by Lionsgate.